**2025 Iowa Football Season Thread**

Joined
Jul 25, 2025
Messages
33
Reaction score
-14
D-line should be loaded, but the sack numbers have to improve.
 

ChipHilton

Hawkeye Historian
Joined
May 24, 2008
Messages
8,482
Reaction score
-198
I don't see the defense as being worse, unless the linebacking is absolutely terrible. DE should be better, potentially much better if Brian Allen finally takes the next step up. Black is a loss at DT, but there are more guys ready to play now. (Yes, I'm counting Hubert and Gaffney in there.) Young Epenesa is a wild card as a depth piece.

Last year, Castro wasn't the same guy as '24 and the safeties struggled. Supposedly X is now at his natural position and Entringer is a pro if he stays healthy. Lutmer should be more ready now. Hall got a lot better as the year went on last year. Phil should be able to come up with another serviceable corner.

I do have the uneasy feeling that the ISU game could be effed up by Phil not yet being settled on a corner and the guy getting the first shot is benched for the year AFTER screwing up that game. Still have some bad memories of the Hyde to safety experiment in '11 and DJ Johnson in '19.
 

Gushawk

Likely a Russian Bot Account
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
98,537
Reaction score
38,760
Having Pittman, Hawthorne and Pace should keep them from having to rely on Hubert and Gaffney too much
Pittman is a little meh, imo, but Hubert and Gaffney are likely moreso I suppose. Need a lot of snaps from Graves and the transfers. I assume DEs (Allen/Iose) will be playing a fair amount inside on 3rd/4th and long plays.
 
Last edited:

ChipHilton

Hawkeye Historian
Joined
May 24, 2008
Messages
8,482
Reaction score
-198
Having Pittman, Hawthorne and Pace should keep them from having to rely on Hubert and Gaffney too much
Yeah, but I think we'd be fine if either guy had a dozen snaps to keep the aforementioned fresh.

Pittman is a little meh, imo, but Hubert and Gaffney are likely moreso I suppose. Need a lot of snaps from Graves and the transfers. I assume DEs will playing a fair amount inside on 3rd/4th and long plays.
I'm a sentimental fool, but I loved Gaffney and Hubert as walk-ons. Gaffney had as good a motor as I've even seen in HS highlight films, but he was 6-2 and 240 and not a DE. Hubert was a tweener; a good HS pass rusher, but not athletic enough for D1 at that position and not big enough to be recruited as a DT. But they looked better than a lot of the scholarship guys Iowa signed in the bleak '08-'15 recruiting years. You hoped they could be something by year 4 and now they've stuck it out to year 4. So I must root.
 

Gushawk

Likely a Russian Bot Account
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
98,537
Reaction score
38,760
A couple poor men’s Matt Neubauers, if you will?
 

Shawneemicks

Has said plenty of things dumber than this
Joined
Feb 20, 2012
Messages
18,252
Reaction score
12,967
The defense is going to be worse if the offense is better. Teams will be more aggressive because they might actually fear Iowa scoring
 
Joined
Jan 9, 2008
Messages
40,788
Reaction score
-5,504
The defense is going to be worse if the offense is better. Teams will be more aggressive because they might actually fear Iowa scoring
Loading 8-9 in the box because we can’t pass, isn’t being aggressive?

Being less aggressive and honest, likely will lower our 3 and outs, keeping the defense rested
 

douglasbader

Said Tom Brady's Career Was Over in 2008
Joined
Aug 3, 2008
Messages
135,588
Reaction score
30,178
The defense is going to be worse if the offense is better. Teams will be more aggressive because they might actually fear Iowa scoring
Sounds like Phil's defense going to ball hawk and get a lot more turnovers.
 

SteadyEddy

HaLo Walk-on
Joined
May 6, 2009
Messages
5,676
Reaction score
4,310
I don't see the defense as being worse, unless the linebacking is absolutely terrible. DE should be better, potentially much better if Brian Allen finally takes the next step up. Black is a loss at DT, but there are more guys ready to play now. (Yes, I'm counting Hubert and Gaffney in there.) Young Epenesa is a wild card as a depth piece.

Last year, Castro wasn't the same guy as '24 and the safeties struggled. Supposedly X is now at his natural position and Entringer is a pro if he stays healthy. Lutmer should be more ready now. Hall got a lot better as the year went on last year. Phil should be able to come up with another serviceable corner.

I do have the uneasy feeling that the ISU game could be effed up by Phil not yet being settled on a corner and the guy getting the first shot is benched for the year AFTER screwing up that game. Still have some bad memories of the Hyde to safety experiment in '11 and DJ Johnson in '19.
I just want to crawl up into that big beautiful Hawkeye brain of yours and nuzzle into all the memories I forgot or beer forgot for me.
 

Monster

Guaranteed Proctor Would Play For Iowa
Joined
Sep 20, 2007
Messages
111,229
Reaction score
-1,306
Loading 8-9 in the box because we can’t pass, isn’t being aggressive?

Being less aggressive and honest, likely will lower our 3 and outs, keeping the defense rested
A better offense means more possessions for both sides of the ball. It's unrealistic to expect the offense to make another leap without seeing defensive stats decrease at least a little.
 

Gushawk

Likely a Russian Bot Account
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
98,537
Reaction score
38,760
A better offense means more possessions for both sides of the ball. It's unrealistic to expect the offense to make another leap without seeing defensive stats decrease at least a little.
sort of matters how it’s better and what you’re measuring (points per game, yards per play, etc). if it’s significantly more explosive, sure. significantly fewer 3 and outs and punts from deep in your own territory, not so much.
 

Monster

Guaranteed Proctor Would Play For Iowa
Joined
Sep 20, 2007
Messages
111,229
Reaction score
-1,306
sort of matters how it’s better and what you’re measuring (points per game, yards per play, etc). if it’s significantly more explosive, sure. significantly fewer 3 and outs and punts from deep in your own territory, not so much.
Points, gus. Always points. No team has ever lost a game based on how many yards they allowed.
 

cloudhawk

Special
Joined
Sep 4, 2007
Messages
100,019,468
Reaction score
14,090
I mean, can you imagine the smorgasbord of running more than 3 plays- scoring more than 20 pts- having a good defense- AND a punting game
 

Hawkstrat

Might Need to GFH
Joined
Dec 5, 2007
Messages
22,638
Reaction score
4,515
A better offense means more possessions for both sides of the ball. It's unrealistic to expect the offense to make another leap without seeing defensive stats decrease at least a little.

I'm not sure that follows. Unless you think a better offense means Iowa's time of possession will shrink. On some drives, a long TD pass will in theory increase possessions for both teams, but converting more first downs should do the opposite.

Shawnee's argument is that opponents played it safe, knowing Iowa couldn't score.

*I didn't see Gus' post saying the same thing.
 

L. Wade Childress

Too stupid to be real
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Messages
88,408
Reaction score
1,521
A better offense means more possessions for both sides of the ball. It's unrealistic to expect the offense to make another leap without seeing defensive stats decrease at least a little.
a better offense does not automatically mean more possessions. A better offense will result in our offense actually accomplishing what Kirk THINKS it already been doing, which is protecting the defense.

of course Kirk is an offensive dumbfuck and doesn’t understand why 3 and outs are bad.
 

Hawk&Balls

NOT a member
Joined
May 1, 2016
Messages
51,040
Reaction score
37,123
It would be more realistic for Iowa that a better offense would be fewer possessions. Better offense for us is going to be longer drives and a lot fewer 3 and outs.
 

douglasbader

Said Tom Brady's Career Was Over in 2008
Joined
Aug 3, 2008
Messages
135,588
Reaction score
30,178
Yeah, the Kirk dream scenario is even if they don't score they are no longer going 3 and out and at a minimum now punting from the 50 instead of punting from the current 27 yard line after a 3 and out. Opponents starting their drives from their own 8 yard line instead of the 30 yard line is a game changer wet dream for Kirk and Phil.
 

cloudhawk

Special
Joined
Sep 4, 2007
Messages
100,019,468
Reaction score
14,090
I think to overall point we are trying to highlight is having a serviceable offense will be a nice option to have again.
 

Monster

Guaranteed Proctor Would Play For Iowa
Joined
Sep 20, 2007
Messages
111,229
Reaction score
-1,306
a better offense does not automatically mean more possessions. A better offense will result in our offense actually accomplishing what Kirk THINKS it already been doing, which is protecting the defense.

of course Kirk is an offensive dumbfuck and doesn’t understand why 3 and outs are bad.
Generally speaking, a higher scoring offense creates more possessions. So yeah I guess not automatically but generally.
 

Monster

Guaranteed Proctor Would Play For Iowa
Joined
Sep 20, 2007
Messages
111,229
Reaction score
-1,306
I'm not sure that follows. Unless you think a better offense means Iowa's time of possession will shrink. On some drives, a long TD pass will in theory increase possessions for both teams, but converting more first downs should do the opposite.

Shawnee's argument is that opponents played it safe, knowing Iowa couldn't score.

*I didn't see Gus' post saying the same thing.
Again, a better offense that scores more creates more possessions. Not sure how that's even arguable.
 

cloudhawk

Special
Joined
Sep 4, 2007
Messages
100,019,468
Reaction score
14,090
We talkin' ball control rushing offense or MACtion in here
 
Top