Iowa State Football Bashing Thread

newsbreaker

Got the top grade in his torts class
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Messages
100,425
Reaction score
22,718
So dumb. Iowa State can still have sports without money from the state. What exactly does Central Iowa get out of Iowa State spending 20.5 million in revenue sharing?
Without ISU athletics, the businesses Jamie is trying to compete with in his vanity project won’t exist. It’s very important they survive until he runs them out of business.
 

Brad Wesley

Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2020
Messages
5,737
Reaction score
5,560
I can’t stand Pollard’s voice so I’m not watching him whine.

After the settlement money is paid, can’t ISU simply choose not to pay the players from revenues and source all NIL payments from the little guy?
 

newsbreaker

Got the top grade in his torts class
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Messages
100,425
Reaction score
22,718
I can’t stand Pollard’s voice so I’m not watching him whine.

After the settlement money is paid, can’t ISU simply choose not to pay the players from revenues and source all NIL payments from the little guy?
I believe they can opt out of revenue sharing, but then their recruiting becomes impossible.

Ultimately, this is what may end up kneecapping the B12 and ACC. A lot of schools there don't have excess revenue to share. What he's really asking for is for the Legislature to give him the 20M a year to pay the players.
 

Thomas Wolsey

Likes Your Post
Joined
Oct 16, 2017
Messages
25,495
Reaction score
23,381
I believe they can opt out of revenue sharing, but then their recruiting becomes impossible.

Ultimately, this is what may end up kneecapping the B12 and ACC. A lot of schools there don't have excess revenue to share. What he's really asking for is for the Legislature to give him the 20M a year to pay the players.
Which should be a nonstarter, but this might also be the worst state legislature in America.
 

Silky Johnson

Might Need to GFH
Joined
Aug 2, 2017
Messages
1,218
Reaction score
1,137
Yeah, if you’re gonna do that just go all the way and have the state itself run a minor league team.
 

KitKatApples

NW Season Ticket Holder (except IA games)
Joined
Aug 5, 2010
Messages
40,135
Reaction score
34,843
I believe they can opt out of revenue sharing, but then their recruiting becomes impossible.

Ultimately, this is what may end up kneecapping the B12 and ACC. A lot of schools there don't have excess revenue to share. What he's really asking for is for the Legislature to give him the 20M a year to pay the players.
Quiet Laugh GIFs | Tenor
 
Last edited:

Soda Popinski

Kelly Hilpiper
Joined
Aug 29, 2007
Messages
41,058
Reaction score
-5,294
I believe they can opt out of revenue sharing, but then their recruiting becomes impossible.

Ultimately, this is what may end up kneecapping the B12 and ACC. A lot of schools there don't have excess revenue to share. What he's really asking for is for the Legislature to give him the 20M a year to pay the players.
Fuck that. There's nothing special about Iowa State that the Legislature should be giving them a pile of cash the other schools don't get.

Eat shit, Jamie.
 

newsbreaker

Got the top grade in his torts class
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Messages
100,425
Reaction score
22,718
Which should be a nonstarter, but this might also be the worst state legislature in America.
Funding for the state regents schools has been declining for decades. I don't think it's as likely as 10 or 20 years ago.

What they might do is let the school redirect general fund money, which is only hurting the core mission of the university so fat Carl can watch their teams play particular opponents.

Should Drake and UNI also get this money?

Why not Loras and Dordt?
Obviously brining up private colleges is stupid, as they aren't stated funded, but UNI will be making all kinds of arguments. They've been fiscally responsible, to their serious competitive detriment, and have been doing a frankly incredible job of private fundraising for facilities improvements, considering their alumni base and size.

But if ISU is going to get a straight appropriation for athletics, there is no argument why UNI (and Iowa) shouldn't receive the same.
 

Brad Wesley

Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2020
Messages
5,737
Reaction score
5,560
I believe they can opt out of revenue sharing, but then their recruiting becomes impossible.

Ultimately, this is what may end up kneecapping the B12 and ACC. A lot of schools there don't have excess revenue to share. What he's really asking for is for the Legislature to give him the 20M a year to pay the players.

My guess is that most public Big 12 schools are having similar problems which should provide a competitive market for recruiting within the conference.

Pollard is the ultimate weasel. I can see him twisting this argument suggesting that other sports will have to be eliminated if he doesn’t get a bailout. The answer is obvious. Live within your means. Sure, they won’t be able to compete against P2 schools for high end recruits, and they will lose most of their talent, but ultimately they can still maintain a football program, albeit a shitty one from a national perspective.
 

newsbreaker

Got the top grade in his torts class
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Messages
100,425
Reaction score
22,718
My guess is that most public Big 12 schools are having similar problems which should provide a competitive market for recruiting within the conference.

Pollard is the ultimate weasel. I can see him twisting this argument suggesting that other sports will have to be eliminated if he doesn’t get a bailout. The answer is obvious. Live within your means. Sure, they won’t be able to compete against P2 schools for high end recruits, and they will lose most of their talent, but ultimately they can still maintain a football program, albeit a shitty one from a national perspective.
Aren't they at the FBS minimum, for number of sports? If they aren't, they're very close.

Even the MWC schools are opting in to "revenue sharing," and most are going to go to the maximum amount (20M) even though it's a larger percentage of their revenues. The American Conference has set at 10M minimum for their schools. I'd guess CUSA will do something similar.
 

L. Wade Childress

Too stupid to be real
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Messages
82,456
Reaction score
1,647
My guess is that most public Big 12 schools are having similar problems which should provide a competitive market for recruiting within the conference.

Pollard is the ultimate weasel. I can see him twisting this argument suggesting that other sports will have to be eliminated if he doesn’t get a bailout. The answer is obvious. Live within your means. Sure, they won’t be able to compete against P2 schools for high end recruits, and they will lose most of their talent, but ultimately they can still maintain a football program, albeit a shitty one from a national perspective.
also, don’t build strip malls when many other strip malls are sitting empty.
 

newsbreaker

Got the top grade in his torts class
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Messages
100,425
Reaction score
22,718
Have they even put a shovel in the ground yet? I remain unconvinced the project will happen.
Yes. The medical clinic is being built, and they've done a bunch of "infrastructure" work. None of the other buildings are under construction, though.
 

Brad Wesley

Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2020
Messages
5,737
Reaction score
5,560
Aren't they at the FBS minimum, for number of sports? If they aren't, they're very close.

Even the MWC schools are opting in to "revenue sharing," and most are going to go to the maximum amount (20M) even though it's a larger percentage of their revenues. The American Conference has set at 10M minimum for their schools. I'd guess CUSA will do something similar.
I don’t know, but would assume they’re flirting with FBS minimum.

If the Big 12 sets rev share min and a ISU can’t make it work? Where do they go?

The longer we discuss this, the more likely it is they get the money somehow. Perhaps it’s my pessimistic nature, but I don’t see the legislature not caving. Hope I’m wrong.
 

Thomas Wolsey

Likes Your Post
Joined
Oct 16, 2017
Messages
25,495
Reaction score
23,381
I don’t know, but would assume they’re flirting with FBS minimum.

If the Big 12 sets rev share min and a ISU can’t make it work? Where do they go?

The longer we discuss this, the more likely it is they get the money somehow. Perhaps it’s my pessimistic nature, but I don’t see the legislature not caving. Hope I’m wrong.
Maybe they will have to take money from their cross country and golf programs.
 

KitKatApples

NW Season Ticket Holder (except IA games)
Joined
Aug 5, 2010
Messages
40,135
Reaction score
34,843
Aren't they at the FBS minimum, for number of sports? If they aren't, they're very close.

Even the MWC schools are opting in to "revenue sharing," and most are going to go to the maximum amount (20M) even though it's a larger percentage of their revenues. The American Conference has set at 10M minimum for their schools. I'd guess CUSA will do something similar.
I don’t know, but would assume they’re flirting with FBS minimum.

If the Big 12 sets rev share min and a ISU can’t make it work? Where do they go?

The longer we discuss this, the more likely it is they get the money somehow. Perhaps it’s my pessimistic nature, but I don’t see the legislature not caving. Hope I’m wrong.
They are at the minimum. Also LOL at not even being able to afford to be in the Mountain West too.
 

fossilhawk

Might Need to GFH
Joined
Dec 15, 2007
Messages
819
Reaction score
1,519
Maybe, and this is a big maybe, Pollard shouldn't have saddled ISU with massive development costs for his little boondoggle at the same time NIL became a thing.

And I think their AD already gets money from the general fund to operate stuff like C. Y. Stephens, which if memory serves has eight figures of deferred maintenance costs pending.

They might be painting themselves into a corner with a notoriously cheap fanbase looking at less disposable income from tariffs, a state legislature that is hostile to increased educational spending and scrambling to plug holes from their own boondoggle, and a university administration which is probably hostile to subsidizing athletics.

One also observes that Wendy Wintersteen will retire in January. Curious timing.
 

Talkin' Goat

Lothario
Joined
Dec 27, 2007
Messages
14,257
Reaction score
996
Maybe, and this is a big maybe, Pollard shouldn't have saddled ISU with massive development costs for his little boondoggle at the same time NIL became a thing.

And I think their AD already gets money from the general fund to operate stuff like C. Y. Stephens, which if memory serves has eight figures of deferred maintenance costs pending.

They might be painting themselves into a corner with a notoriously cheap fanbase looking at less disposable income from tariffs, a state legislature that is hostile to increased educational spending and scrambling to plug holes from their own boondoggle, and a university administration which is probably hostile to subsidizing athletics.

One also observes that Wendy Wintersteen will retire in January. Curious timing.
IIRC the ISU AD isn’t fronting any of the money for the strip mall. Seems like the developer is taking on the initial risk and then getting paid back first, but I don’t recall the specifics. My hope for them to fail miserably and ultimately needing to give up all sports and shut down the AD is still unwavering, though.
 

newsbreaker

Got the top grade in his torts class
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Messages
100,425
Reaction score
22,718
Maybe, and this is a big maybe, Pollard shouldn't have saddled ISU with massive development costs for his little boondoggle at the same time NIL became a thing.

And I think their AD already gets money from the general fund to operate stuff like C. Y. Stephens, which if memory serves has eight figures of deferred maintenance costs pending.

They might be painting themselves into a corner with a notoriously cheap fanbase looking at less disposable income from tariffs, a state legislature that is hostile to increased educational spending and scrambling to plug holes from their own boondoggle, and a university administration which is probably hostile to subsidizing athletics.

One also observes that Wendy Wintersteen will retire in January. Curious timing.
They're planning on using the profits (LOL) from their strip mall to pay for the 100M in deferred maintenance to the "Iowa State Center."
 

newsbreaker

Got the top grade in his torts class
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Messages
100,425
Reaction score
22,718
What happens if it never profits then?
It's a terrific question, and one they should be focused on.

This was all before the House settlement, and I wonder if they'll change their plan now that they're facing some big bills.
 

Talkin' Goat

Lothario
Joined
Dec 27, 2007
Messages
14,257
Reaction score
996
It's a terrific question, and one they should be focused on.

This was all before the House settlement, and I wonder if they'll change their plan now that they're facing some big bills.
Their plan now is to get money directly from the State. Idea being that there will be a decrease in State revenue if ISU athletics are shit and fewer fans are traveling, staying in hotels, spending money, etc. as a result. Not a bad plan honestly as it’s pretty much all Pollard can do, but it’s still fun to watch them squirm. If he somehow does get money out of the state, then even more will need to come to Iowa City based on the same argument. Which is nice.
 

newsbreaker

Got the top grade in his torts class
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Messages
100,425
Reaction score
22,718
He said they burn through their reserves in two years. I wonder how far off they think they are on an annual basis, but it has to be a lot.
 

Brad Wesley

Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2020
Messages
5,737
Reaction score
5,560
Their plan now is to get money directly from the State. Idea being that there will be a decrease in State revenue if ISU athletics are shit and fewer fans are traveling, staying in hotels, spending money, etc. as a result. Not a bad plan honestly
I think it’s the best argument Pollard can make. If they have the money, but just prefer to use it for NIL instead, fuck that. Taxpayer money going to NIL is insane.
 

KitKatApples

NW Season Ticket Holder (except IA games)
Joined
Aug 5, 2010
Messages
40,135
Reaction score
34,843
He said they burn through their reserves in two years. I wonder how far off they think they are on an annual basis, but it has to be a lot.
They always report that they break even at the end of every fiscal year, so where did this reserve come from?
 
Top